There is a clone on the loose in Secret Lives that you need to deal with somehow in Starfield. Should you kill or spare him?
“Secret Lives” is a concise miscellaneous mission that revolves around a clone’s struggle with his genuine identity and the purpose of his existence within the world of Starfield. This quest delves into the themes of paranoia and the haunting origins of the clone, propelling him to seek your guidance for clarity.
The choices you make will steer the narrative in various directions, ultimately yielding different rewards, with some outcomes proving more favorable than others.
Now, let’s explore how you can make the most optimal decisions for Wyatt during the “Secret Lives” mission in Starfield.
How to unlock the Secret Lives mission
In order to access the “Secret Lives” side mission, you must initiate a conversation with Wyatt Earp while undertaking the “Begin Operation Starseed” quest within the Starfield game.
As you progress through the quest, particularly following your discussion with Franklin, you’ll receive a task to investigate the facility where you are scheduled to rendezvous with Wyatt. Subsequently, the Mission HUD will be updated automatically, incorporating “Secret Lives” within the Miscellaneous tab.
How to complete Secret Lives in Starfield
Embark on a journey to the facility Franklin mentioned during Operation Starseed. This facility is situated within the Crucible on Charybdis III, nestled within the Charybdis System.
Upon your arrival, proceed directly from the landing site towards the facility. Wyatt will intercept you along the way, eager to divulge information regarding Roosevelt. He insists on a private conversation outside the city, specifically within a cave, ideally before you delve into the Facility.
You have two options: you can either follow Wyatt to the designated cave or, alternatively, take a right turn behind the nearby buildings, leading you into the forest where you’ll find the cave Wyatt awaits outside of. If it happens to be nighttime, remember to activate your flashlight to illuminate the slightly concealed cave entrance.
In this secluded setting, Wyatt confides in you, revealing that he is not Wyatt Harp but rather a clone of America’s infamous first serial killer, H.H. Holmes. He is plagued by anxiety concerning potential repercussions and threats to both himself and future clones if his true identity were to be unveiled within the Facility.
Should you kill or spare Holmes’ clone?
The Holmes clone, suspecting you to be an assassin sent to eliminate him, will issue a threat on your life. In this critical juncture within “Secret Lives,” you’ll be presented with two alternatives for handling the clone.
You can opt to terminate him through direct confrontation or choose to spare him by persuading him to reconsider his stance. A third option is available as well, allowing you to disengage from the situation entirely and abandon the mission.
Opting to employ persuasion not only preserves Holmes’s life but also results in a superior reward, as opposed to the alternative outcome where he meets his demise, concluding the quest with a reduced payment. We recommend the persuasion route because it offers a more straightforward resolution, involves no harm to you, and ultimately leads to greater earnings.
Persuade H.H. Holmes (recommended)
Opting to employ persuasion during the “Secret Lives” mission entails successfully navigating a 6-bar persuasion check within the Starfield game.
Begin by choosing the dialogue option featuring the [Persuade] prompt, then proceed to select the +6 red option, allowing you to resolve the persuasion check in one decisive move. This leads to Holmes placing his trust in you and requesting your discretion regarding the entire situation.
Kill (or walk away from) H.H. Holmes
Should you opt to either launch an attack or simply depart from the situation, choosing not to persuade Holmes during the “Secret Lives” mission, he will trigger the attached explosive device within the Starfield game.
This action results in the demise of Holmes, and if your health reserves are dwindling, it may also prove fatal to you. Notably, both of these choices yield identical outcomes and rewards, affording you the flexibility to select either path.
Following your decision among these three options, you will observe the ensuing consequences and successfully conclude the mission in Starfield.
Starfield – Secret Lives mission rewards